If you haven’t heard already, the West Bend Library is immersed in controversy over whether or not books that contain explicit, adult-oriented material should be moved from the library’s young adult section to the regular adult section.
Those opposed to moving the books consider the proposal to be censorship.
I’m on the record as stating that both sides of the West Bend Library issue are flawed and unable to look at things logically. Last night’s library board meeting only highlighted my sentiments.
The side that wants to move the books is backed by an ultra-religious group that thinks that supplemental pro-Christian material (pamphlets, etc.) should be placed in the library to balance out all of “the smut.” Last night, in fact, one of the “move the books” proponents went as far as to say that books like Harry Potter should be torn up and burned.
Whooooooa, pops. You lost me.
There are books in the young adult (11-15 years old) section that talk about fellatio and all sorts of other sexual acts in great detail. I would feel more comfortable with the library moving those books the regular grown-up section. But burning books? Sorry, Hitler, this is America. We don’t do that here.
The problem with the opposing side is that they come off like they are forcing sexuality down everybody’s throat (so to speak). They say that sexually explicit books should be left in the youth section so that parents “have the choice” of whether or not their kids should be able to read them.
The “parents’ choice” concept sounds reasonable, but then that group also brings kids’ sexuality into the argument. Some of their speakers over the last few months have talked about their own sexuality and how hard it was for them as homosexual teens growing up. They use the adversity that they experienced as an argument for keeping the books where they currently reside.
This issue isn’t about being gay or straight, it’s about sexually explicit books that are mixed in with books written for 11-year-old children.
As a logical parent, without religious or sexual agendas, I would much rather see the books moved to the grown-ups’ section. Moving them still allows parents the ability to dictate what their children read, and since there are no age restrictions on any areas in the library, there is no actual censorship taking place. Everyone is a winner.
Last night, however, the board decided to leave the books amongst the rest. After hearing those screaming about burning books and how God was going to strike them down, there was no way that the board could have sided with those people. I don’t like their decision, but it was the right one at this time.